Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"[AAPL] cuts the government's case to shreds"

Wow, is CNN a news organization or a press release promotion mill?

CNN's one-sidedness made me uneasy enough to research the contrarian opinion, this is the best summary I found:

http://paidcontent.org/2012/05/14/e-book-class-action-new-de...

Effectively the evidence in the govt's case shows that:

a) AAPL recognized that they required the collusion of the top 5 publishers to set market pricing, and actively solicited them.

b) AAPL suggested pricing to the top 5 publishers.

I believe in due process, just pointing out that there is clearly more here than CNN's summary allows.



It's a CNN-branded opinion blog covering Apple, not a CNN news report.


I searched the page for the words blog, opinion, and editorial => zero matches. It does look like an opinion piece, but they should at least label it as such.


When I saw the words "Bite Me" in the title, it set certain expectations for what was to follow. I would have been surprised had it been anything but an opinion piece.


How is it price fixing when it's in your own store only?


The "most-favored nation" clause makes it so that it applies to all stores, not just yours.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: