Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Amazing. I had no idea Apple could just arbitrarily (or even with great reasons) decide to shut down your Apple ID, killing your software and disable a lifetime of DRM protected music, ebook and application purchases. Reminds me of how you now must show a passport to leave the US and being behind on your child support is cause to prevent US citizens from leaving the country, just as if they lived in East Germany. Starts out, oh sure, we need this system to check to make sure you're not some kind of criminal. Then it is used for arbitrary control and enforcement of the whims of a cold centralized bureaucracy.

Cough cough Stallman was right cough cough.



Still worse, if you're an indie iOS developer they can yank your entire living out from under you without explanation. This happened to me this year, I suspect because I made some app store purchases while traveling abroad. They disabled my ID and refused to even tell me why and only reinstated it after a long and arduous exchange with support.

I really enjoy developing for iOS but this was a sobering experience.


There are no "indie" iOS developers, because iOS developers are not independent. There are only "iOS contract developers", paid on a royalty basis, but retained at-will by Apple.


Is it common to use the same Apple ID for personal purchases and your business app development?


It sure seems like a bad idea now, doesn't it?


I know a lot of devs. For the ones who do it full time, almost none of them do this.


you now must show a passport to leave the US

Since when do you have to show a passport to leave the US? All you have to do is prove that you are eligible to enter the country you are traveling to. (This is strictly a money thing: the airline doesn't want to transport you to another country where you'll be refused entry, because then they'll have to fly you back, which costs them money. So you show a passport at checkin and they save money, making your ticket cheaper.)


That's when you check-in and get your boarding pass issued. After that, many countries (not sure how it works in the US now) have an immigration check point where you're supposed to show your passport (probably to check if you've overstayed on your visit). Some places don't have this check - I noticed that London doesn't. I'm guessing America started enforcing this check as well recently.


The US does not have exit immigration. Airlines have to ask for your passport to ensure that you meet the entry requirements of your destination country. If an airline transports a passenger who is then denied entry, that airline will be fined and on the hook for getting the passenger out again. Generally they can recoup these fines from the passenger but it's a pain and they don't want to deal with it.

The EU and Japan, for instance, do have exit checks. These are done by the relevant immigration bureaus. The passport checks performed by airline personnel are completely different and bear no impact on one's ability to leave the US.

As an aside, this is the reason that most international connection at US airports require a visa. US airports (with LAX being the sole exception, AFAIK) have no way to monitor anyone leaving the secure area. Nothing would stop passengers in transit between international flights from simply leaving. Connecting in, say, Tokyo-Narita doesn't require entering Japan because everyone in the secure area has either exited Japan or is in transit in the sterile zone.

The only exception is passengers on Air New Zealand's Auckland-LAX-London run and Air France's Paris-LAX-Tahiti flight, though I may be wrong. Special arrangements have been set up for these flights.


  The EU and Japan, for instance, do have exit checks.
Not if you leave from an airport in the Schengen area to another Schengen airport.

Some airports may check your ID (and determine if it matches your boarding pass) before allowing you into the restricted, passenger only area. But others don't. In Vienna and Zurich you just automatically scan the bar code on the boarding pass and an automatic gate admits you. Some of the gates now even have automated gates where you scan your boarding pass and get admitted to the plane.

There is also no entrance check, when you arrive from a Schengen airport.

I usually don't need an id when flying within Schengen (Prague being one of the exceptions), just the boarding pass, which I usually print at home.

Please note that I don't recommend not to carry id. Even if you're usually not asked. If they do check at the gate you're quite obviously not boarding when you don't have a valid id.


Schengen is a lot like the "states" of the US. If I want to travel from New York to Illinois, there is absolutely no government intervention.

Schengen is a great system. I've taken the train between Denmark and Germany and it's not much different from commuting to work in the same city :)


Of course, excuse my Amero-centrism. I should've written that the Schengen Zone does not have exit checks, which is what I meant when I mistakenly wrote "EU."

I miss my time in Europe. Flying around Schengen nations is so much easier than between states these days.


The US does not have exit immigration.

That's not entirely accurate. Since the arrival of the US-VISIT program, visa holders need to record their departure. At least at some locations and times, this was done with a mobile "pseudo-checkpoint" near the gate area. You weren't required to talk to them, though.


Ah, I wasn't aware of that requirement for foreign citizens leaving the US.

I suppose my comment should be revised to say "The US does not have exit immigration for its own citizens."


The US only has immigration and customs checkpoints on the way in, not on the way out.


Reminds me of how you now must show a passport to leave the US and being behind on your child support is cause to prevent US citizens from leaving the country, just as if they lived in East Germany.

Curious, what country did you travel to that you experienced this?

Driving across the border to Canada recently I did not have to talk to or interact with anyone from US Customs.


I should point out that Apple no longer offers any music with DRM.


The Japan iTunes music store is still mostly FairPlay-protected.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: